before you read... theres grammar mistakes in this entry, there's also some things you may not understand because they are unpolished gems from the mind of a futterman, and i ramble, but please give it a try and try to see what i mean. it's not a four-paragraph thing, and it's not a thousand pages long, but i think i made my point, if you can pick it out of the mess.
what am i thinking about from the catcher in the rye? i love the book, thats obvious, but how the hell am i supposed to write a decent entry about it when its main character is an easily distracted little person who goes off on long,. drawn out monologues generously seasoned with goddamn's and phonies? where is there to go? i just read and follow the story as its told, and maybe here and there there's some bits of wisdom sprouting, but my mental capacity's too small to come up with anything deep concerning the coming of age experience of holden caulfield. maybe someone would say the moment he left pencey, his private school, before he was told, was the moment he transformed into an adult. i hardly thik this is evidence, as the kid was kicked out for his bad grades and had just spent the night complaining about his roommates. but wait...maybe thats it! ok, so holden spends the very first part of the book talking to stuffy teachers and whining about his school life, but the minute he leaves, he complains more...ok, so thats not it either. maybe coming of age is realizing that you can still complain and by cynical and act like a child while maintaining your maturity. everybody wants holden to be this big man who gets good grades, and people look down on him because he goes on mindless rants that actually aren't mindless, and they're all so condescending because they wont give him drinks at bars and he knows vain men who spend their time horsing around with no-g00d girls and combing their hair in mirrors, and everyone just tells him to be like them, but maybe their views of adulthood are all wrong! maybe that's the reason why holden's so cynical, because everything is just operating incorrectly and he doesn't even know it! its just instincts! and when he calls people morons, it's not because he thinks they're stupid, but maybe because he has this internal mechanism that tells him that everyone who misunderstands him is wrong, and he just uses the only vocabulary he knows, which is heavily dosed with "morons. "
i cant do this. i cannot come to a logical, deep conclusion. what do people expect from me! i'm not freud, or any of those other guys with high iq's, right? when i try so hard to create a good piece of writing that will get me a decent grade all i get is this, some lame excuse for a "thoughtful" entry. how can i write about holden when he doesn't want to be written about? how can i write about rebellion and coming of age when they just want to be left alone to fester in the stomachs of youth? how can i compress it into a rectangle when all it wants to do is be a formless mess on the floor? JD Salinger ended up a recluse and wouldnt let them make a movie based on the book. The Catcher in The Rye was instantly popular but did he care? does holden care? Do rebels need to be publicized in glamour shots and gushing reviews?
so this, i believe, is the philosophy of holden caulfield, and salinger, and everyone who comes of age... it's not something that should be glamourized. holden's rants are seamless and formless and go in different directions, but he is the true image of the coming of age experience. what i'm trying to say is that the only true way you can capture rebellion in a novel is to make it squishy... passionate... long and drawn our with maybe a few or more hints of madness thrown in.
Annie--I admire your honesty here, and I think that anger about fitting into boxes is exactly what Salinger would have wanted...remember that reading is an exercise for the brain, and my hope is that you let it take you in all directions. sometimes it takes courage to step out of what you think the teacher wants...but know that what I have been looking for in blog posts all year is an honest response from an engaged reader. There are times when you have to squeeze your thoughts into a format, but this isn't one of them...and I think it can be dangerous to try to make your ideas fit into someone else's expectations. Own your thoughts. They are good ones.
ReplyDelete